Understanding cigar butt investing: A Guide to Warren Buffett's Approach
What is cigar butt investing?
Cigar butt investing refers to purchasing shares of companies that have been beaten down by the market and are trading for less than their intrinsic value. The idea comes from picking up a discarded cigar butt on the street—there’s one last puff left for free. Similarly, these businesses are near the end of their operational life but may still provide a quick profit if bought at a sufficiently low price and sold when their stock price rises slightly.
Key Takeaway: Cigar butt investing involves targeting distressed companies for short-term gains, but the risks can outweigh the rewards for inexperienced investors.
Definition of cigar butt investing
How does the cigar butt approach work?
In the cigar butt approach, investors look for companies trading at a deep discount to their net current asset value (NCAV). The formula for NCAV is to subtract all liabilities, including debts, from the company's current assets. If the resulting value divided by the number of outstanding shares is higher than the stock’s current price, the company may be worth investing in.
Once the stock is purchased, the investor waits for the market to recognize the undervaluation and for the price to increase. This approach to investing is about capitalizing on a temporary price rise before the company potentially liquidates or fails.
Key Takeaway: The cigar butt approach involves buying stocks at a discount, hoping for a short-term price recovery, but timing and analysis are crucial.
Key principles of the cigar butt investing strategy
There are several key principles that investors must follow when engaging in cigar butt investing. The first is understanding the company's liquidation value—how much it would be worth if its assets were sold and liabilities paid. Investors should also focus on stocks with low price-to-earnings ratios and other valuation metrics that suggest the company is undervalued. The last puff strategy relies heavily on buying a stock at a sufficiently low price and taking advantage of market corrections.
However, it is essential to note that not all undervalued companies are good investments. Many may continue to decline or face financial troubles that prevent any recovery.
Key Takeaway: Cigar butt investing requires careful financial analysis to ensure a company’s value exceeds its liabilities, but risks are high.
How did Warren Buffett influence cigar butt investing?
Warren Buffett is one of the most famous proponents of cigar butt investing, especially during his early career. He applied this strategy to purchase shares in companies trading below their net current asset value. His philosophy was to take advantage of undervalued stocks and sell them for a profit when the market eventually recognized their worth. One notable example was his early investment in Berkshire Hathaway, which was a classic cigar butt company.
Key Takeaway: Warren Buffett's early experiences shaped his investment philosophy, helping him generate significant returns with cigar butt investing before transitioning to other strategies.
Warren Buffett's early experiences with cigar butt companies
Buffett’s early career was marked by his preference for buying companies that were trading well below their liquidation value. These businesses were often in financial trouble but had enough assets left to provide a profit. One of his most famous cigar butt investments was Berkshire Hathaway itself, which was a struggling textile mill. Buffett later realized that although these investments could yield short-term gains, they were often high-risk.
Key Takeaway: Buffett's early experiences with cigar butt companies, like Berkshire Hathaway, highlighted both the opportunities and limitations of this strategy.
Lessons learned from Berkshire Hathaway's investments
Although Berkshire Hathaway provided Buffett with initial profits through the cigar butt approach, he eventually recognized the flaws in this strategy. Buffett realized that the long-term success of an investment depends on the underlying business quality rather than just its stock price. This led him to shift his focus to high-quality companies with strong fundamentals, marking his departure from the cigar butt philosophy.
Key Takeaway: The lessons Buffett learned from Berkshire Hathaway transformed his investing style from focusing on beaten-down companies to prioritizing businesses with long-term potential.
Comparison with Buffett’s other investing strategies
Over time, Warren Buffett moved away from the cigar butt approach to value investing, which focuses on finding high-quality companies trading below their intrinsic value. Unlike cigar butt investing, value investing is more about the long-term performance of strong businesses rather than short-term gains from distressed ones. Buffett’s later investments, such as Coca-Cola and Apple, exemplify this shift towards sustainable growth.
Key Takeaway: While cigar butt investing can provide short-term gains, Buffett’s transition to value investing highlights the importance of focusing on long-term quality over short-term bargains.
What are cigar butt companies?
Cigar butt companies are businesses that have fallen out of favor with investors and are trading at deep discounts, often below their liquidation value. These companies typically have weak financials and poor growth prospects, but their assets still hold value. In the world of cigar butt investing, these companies are seen as opportunities to make a quick profit before their stock price falls further or the company liquidates entirely.
Key Takeaway: Cigar butt companies are those with declining performance but enough remaining assets to offer a short-term profit for savvy investors.
Characteristics of cigar butt companies
Cigar butt companies usually share a few defining characteristics. They often have deteriorating business models, declining revenue, or shrinking market share. Their stock’s current trading price is typically well below their liquidation value, meaning the value of their assets exceeds the company’s liabilities. Additionally, their net current asset value (NCAV) often suggests that they are undervalued, despite their poor performance.
These companies might also be dealing with financial distress or unfavorable market conditions, making them unattractive to most investors. However, for those using the cigar butt strategy, these characteristics signal a potential "bargain purchase" that will make that puff worthwhile.
Key Takeaway: Cigar butt companies are characterized by weak performance but are often trading below their liquidation value, presenting opportunities for short-term profits.
Examples of successful cigar butt investments
One of the most famous examples of a cigar butt investment is Warren Buffett’s early purchase of Berkshire Hathaway, a struggling textile company at the time. Buffett recognized that the company’s stock was trading below its net current asset value, offering a chance to unload the shares later for a profit. Another example is the famous investment by Benjamin Graham, the father of value investing, who frequently bought shares in companies with only "one puff left in it," knowing he could extract some remaining value.
These investments demonstrated that even distressed companies could provide the highest returns of his career when bought at sufficiently low prices.
Key Takeaway: Successful cigar butt investments like Berkshire Hathaway and Benjamin Graham’s investments show that careful evaluation can lead to significant returns, even in struggling companies.
Risks associated with investing in cigar butts
While the cigar butt strategy can yield quick profits, it comes with significant risks. One of the primary dangers is that the company’s stock price may not recover, leaving the investor holding shares in a failing business. In many cases, these companies have deeply embedded problems, and their short-term prospects may not offer much of a smoke.
Additionally, in companies nearing liquidation, preferred shareholders and debt holders often get paid first, leaving common shareholders with little or nothing. Moreover, the time it takes for a stock to recover may be longer than anticipated, resulting in poor returns.
Key Takeaway: The cigar butt strategy carries considerable risks, including the potential for prolonged recovery periods and liquidation scenarios where common shareholders may not be fully compensated.
How to evaluate a cigar butt investment?
Evaluating a cigar butt investment involves looking beyond the company’s poor performance to assess its true value. This begins with understanding the company’s net current asset value (NCAV), which can help identify undervalued stocks. NCAV is calculated by subtracting total liabilities from the company’s current assets and dividing this figure by the number of common shares. If the stock’s current trading price is lower than the resulting value, the company may be a good candidate for cigar butt investing.
Investors should also evaluate the company’s management, industry position, and likelihood of a short-term recovery. The goal is to find a "bargain purchase" where the final puff will be worth the initial investment.
Key Takeaway: Successful cigar butt investing requires a thorough evaluation of a company’s NCAV, management, and potential for short-term recovery to ensure a profitable exit.
Understanding net current asset value (NCAV)
Net current asset value (NCAV) is a crucial metric in the cigar butt approach. It reflects the total value of a company’s current assets after all liabilities are subtracted. The NCAV is then divided by the number of common shares to determine how much value each share represents if the company were to liquidate its assets. If a stock’s current trading price is significantly lower than its NCAV, it may signal an opportunity for cigar butt investors.
NCAV serves as a baseline for assessing whether a company is undervalued. It’s an essential tool in determining whether the stock price has enough cushion to protect against further losses.
Key Takeaway: NCAV helps investors determine if a company’s assets outweigh its liabilities, making it a key metric in identifying undervalued cigar butt companies.
Assessing the liquidation value of a company
The liquidation value of a company is the total worth of its assets if it were to cease operations and sell everything. This value includes cash, inventory, and receivables but excludes intangible assets like goodwill. Cigar butt investors focus on companies whose liquidation value exceeds their current stock price, providing a safety net for the investment. To evaluate liquidation value, investors subtract the company’s total liabilities from its tangible assets.
While liquidation value can offer some assurance, it’s important to note that a company’s actual liquidation might not occur, and even if it does, common shareholders are often the last to get paid.
Key Takeaway: Understanding a company’s liquidation value is crucial for cigar butt investors to ensure that their investment has a sufficient margin of safety in case the company fails.
Identifying potential bargains in the market
Finding potential cigar butt investments requires a keen eye for undervalued stocks. Investors can start by screening for companies trading below their NCAV or with low price-to-earnings ratios. Additionally, looking for businesses in distressed industries or undergoing short-term difficulties may uncover hidden gems.
However, these opportunities come with significant risks, and it’s important to combine financial analysis with a good understanding of the company’s long-term prospects. While the "chance to unload" the stock at a higher price is the goal, the investor must be prepared for the possibility that the price may not recover.
Key Takeaway: Identifying cigar butt investments involves finding stocks trading at a deep discount, but the potential rewards must be weighed against the considerable risks.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of cigar butt investing?
Benefits of the cigar butt investing approach
One of the primary benefits of the cigar butt investing strategy is that it allows investors to purchase companies at a deep discount to their intrinsic value. When companies are trading for less than their liquidation value, there’s a clear margin of safety. For example, if a company’s stock price is lower than its net current asset value (NCAV), it indicates the stock is undervalued.
Another advantage is the potential for quick profits. Because this is a short-term approach, investors can often sell the stock after a brief uptick in price, achieving a return without holding the investment for long. Many consider this strategy rewarding because it leverages the last gasp of value from struggling companies, much like finding a "cheap" business with "one good puff left."
Key Takeaway: The cigar butt investing approach offers opportunities to buy undervalued stocks at a discount, providing a margin of safety and potential for short-term profits.
Challenges faced by investors using this strategy
Despite its potential rewards, cigar butt investing presents significant challenges. One of the main difficulties is identifying companies that are truly undervalued and not simply on the path to liquidation. Even when a business appears to have value left, unforeseen financial issues may arise, leading to losses.
Furthermore, companies trading at a discount to their liquidation value often face multiple problems, such as poor management or declining market conditions. The “last puff” of value may not be enough to compensate for the risks. Additionally, if a company is liquidated, common shareholders are usually paid after creditors and preferred shareholders, which can result in little or no return for cigar butt investors.
Key Takeaway: Cigar butt investing is a risky strategy, and investors may face challenges such as companies not recovering or offering minimal returns if liquidated.
When to consider alternative investing strategies
Cigar butt investing is not suitable for every investor, and there are times when alternative strategies may be more appropriate. For those seeking long-term, stable returns, value investing or growth investing may offer a better path. If an investor is focused on sustainability and high-quality businesses, they might find that the cigar butt strategy is too speculative and short-term.
It's important to note that cigar butt investing is best used when markets are in downturns, and many companies are trading at depressed prices. In contrast, in bullish markets, where most companies are valued more accurately, value investing might be a more reliable choice.
Key Takeaway: Alternative investing strategies such as value or growth investing should be considered when long-term stability and quality are prioritized over short-term gains.
How does cigar butt investing compare to value investing?
Cigar butt investing and value investing are often confused because both strategies seek out undervalued stocks. However, they are fundamentally different in their approach and objectives. While cigar butt investing focuses on buying companies that are trading at less than their liquidation value, value investing seeks to purchase high-quality companies for less than their intrinsic value.
Cigar butt investing is a short-term strategy that aims to capitalize on temporary price spikes, while value investing is more long-term, focused on the underlying quality and future growth of a company. Warren Buffett famously shifted from the cigar butt approach to value investing because he realized that businesses with "one good puff left" might not offer sustainable returns over time.
Key Takeaway: Cigar butt investing is a short-term approach, while value investing focuses on long-term gains by buying high-quality companies at a discount to their intrinsic value.
Similarities between cigar butt and value investing
Both cigar butt investing and value investing are rooted in the idea of purchasing stocks that are undervalued by the market. The two strategies emphasize buying at a discount, ensuring a margin of safety for investors. They also rely on financial metrics, such as the company’s net current asset value, to assess whether a stock is trading for less than its true value.
Additionally, both approaches were pioneered by Benjamin Graham, the father of value investing. Graham used cigar butt investing during the Great Depression when many companies were trading at a significant discount, illustrating the overlap in their origins.
Key Takeaway: Both cigar butt and value investing seek out undervalued stocks, leveraging a margin of safety to protect investors from potential losses.
Differences in approach and outcomes
The key difference between these two strategies lies in the quality of the companies being invested in. Cigar butt investing focuses on companies at the end of their value potential, often relying on a short-term spike in stock price to realize profits. On the other hand, value investing targets high-quality businesses with strong fundamentals that may be temporarily undervalued by the market.
Outcomes also differ: cigar butt investments often offer quick returns but come with higher risks, while value investing tends to produce more stable, long-term growth. Warren Buffett himself noted that the cigar butt approach worked very well for short-term gains but did not align with his goal of building lasting wealth through sustainable businesses.
Key Takeaway: Cigar butt investing is a short-term, high-risk strategy, while value investing emphasizes long-term growth and quality.
Choosing the right strategy for your investment goals
When deciding between cigar butt investing and value investing, it’s important to consider your personal financial goals. If you are seeking short-term gains and are comfortable with higher risks, the cigar butt strategy may offer opportunities. However, if your goal is long-term wealth creation with lower risk, value investing is likely a better fit.
Warren Buffett’s own transition from cigar butt investing to value investing demonstrates the evolution of an investor's strategy as their goals change. As a result, choosing the right approach depends on whether you prioritize short-term profits or long-term financial security.
Key Takeaway: Choosing between cigar butt investing and value investing depends on your financial goals and risk tolerance—short-term profits or long-term stability.
FAQs
1. What is cigar butt investing?Cigar butt investing is a short-term strategy where investors buy shares of struggling companies trading below their liquidation value. The aim is to profit from a temporary increase in the stock price before the company’s value declines further.
2. How does the cigar butt investing strategy differ from value investing?Cigar butt investing focuses on buying distressed companies with one last "puff" of value left, whereas value investing targets high-quality businesses that are temporarily undervalued but have long-term growth potential.
3. What is net current asset value (NCAV) in cigar butt investing?Net current asset value (NCAV) is calculated by subtracting a company's total liabilities from its current assets. If the stock’s current price is lower than its NCAV, it might be considered a cigar butt investment.
4. Who popularized cigar butt investing?Warren Buffett popularized cigar butt investing during the early stages of his career. He used it to generate some of his highest returns, but eventually moved away from this strategy, favoring long-term value investing.
5. What are the risks associated with cigar butt investing?Cigar butt investing carries the risk that the company may not recover, or the stock price may never spike as expected. Additionally, if the company liquidates, common shareholders are often the last to get paid, which can lead to minimal returns.
6. Is cigar butt investing suitable for all investors?Cigar butt investing is not ideal for every investor due to its high-risk nature. It is best suited for experienced investors comfortable with short-term speculation and capable of analyzing distressed companies effectively.
Fun Fact
Did you know?Warren Buffett once called cigar butt investing the approach of picking up "a discarded cigar butt found on the street that has one puff left in it." Interestingly, one of his most famous cigar butt investments was Berkshire Hathaway, a struggling textile mill, which he later transformed into a multibillion-dollar conglomerate!
Commentaires